Pizza restaurants

Carruso’z Pizza Shop

4.4 27 reviews Closed 7656 Lancaster Ave, Mt Aetna, PA 19544, United States

Discover this place

Located at 7656 Lancaster Ave, Mt Aetna, PA, Carruso’z Pizza Shop stands out as a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts. This family-oriented pizza restaurant prides itself on offering authentic Neapolitan Round Pizza alongside an array of mouthwatering appetizers and hearty pasta dinners. Customers rave about the freshness of their ingredients, evident in dishes like the cheeseburger subs and onion rings, highlighted by a recent review stating, "Amazing food quality, very clean restaurant, great customer service and more!"

The commitment to quality extends to their homemade bread, which adds a delightful touch to every sub. Patrons can indulge in classic Italian dishes such as Pasta with Tomato Sauce or Lasagna at reasonable prices, making it a fantastic value for families. The consistent praise for the warmth of the staff creates an inviting atmosphere, as noted by Andrew Rowland, who felt treated like family during his visit. With a dedication to serving satisfying meals and fostering a community spirit, Carruso’z Pizza Shop undoubtedly holds a special place in the hearts of locals, earning its reputation as one of Mt Aetna’s top dining spots.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Carruso’z Pizza Shop before visiting.

Reviews for Carruso’z Pizza Shop

4.4

27 reviews

100%

27%

12%

Review highlights

Based on 27 reviews

Carruso’z Pizza Shop in Mt Aetna, PA, is widely appreciated for its fresh, homemade bread and high-quality ingredients, contributing to a standout dining experience. Customers frequently highlight the friendly, family-like atmosphere and attentive customer service, which adds a personal touch to visits. The menu variety, especially the cheeseburger subs, onion rings, and cheesesteak options, receives consistent praise for flavor and freshness. The restaurant’s cleanliness and efficient order fulfillment, including accommodating special requests, also form part of the positive feedback. Overall, Carruso’z Pizza Shop is regarded as a reliable and enjoyable spot for both families and individuals seeking consistently well-prepared and satisfying meals.

Andrew Rowland

Aug 17, 2025

We got a sub from this pizza place. They must make their own bread because it was very fresh. They treat their customers like family which was also a great touch.

Andrew B.

Aug 17, 2025

Amazing food, be sure to try the onion ring. Their cheeseburger subs are also tops.

Frederick

Jul 31, 2025

Amazing food quality, very clean restaurant, great customer service and more! I went here with my whole family and i have told my friends about this place and brought them too. Coming from a picky eater i could say with confidence that this place easily makes it to the top best restaurant in the city in my own opinion. This is a place i can eat at everyday.

Kory Hibshman

Jun 22, 2025

Ordered one of each variation of Cheesesteak(Beef) Large, except the hoagie, and a second Chipotle. Five Hot Subs total with the special instruction to cut them into 1/4s. All were completed as I arrived for pick up about 25-30 minutes after I placed the order online. They were all great and the rolls were undoubtedly freshly made. My coworkers and I were all satisfied. The woman working by herself in the their kitchen deserves all the praises given. She did an excellent job and was very thankful for the business. I will definitely order from Carruso's again.